Free starter kit + safety glasses with every laser. Ships from California. Chat with an advisor ›

xTool S1 40W vs Refurbished CO2 Laser: What I Actually Compared for Our Shop

An office administrator's practical comparison of an enclosed diode laser (xTool S1 40W) and a refurbished CO2 laser for a small fabrication shop—covering cost, maintenance, Florida environment factors, and when a sublimation printer or laser welding machine might be the better fit.

Why I was comparing lasers instead of just buying the cheapest one

I handle purchasing for a 65-person fabrication shop. In early 2025 our old laser engraver finally died—third major repair quote was higher than its residual value. So this became my problem again.

We're not glamorous. We do small-batch production—signage, custom jigs, some wood and acrylic fixtures. But the shop runs on it, and when it stops, things don't ship, and then operations comes looking for me.

I had two paths in front of me. A new enclosed diode laser (we ended up looking hard at the xTool S1 40W) or a refurbished CO2 laser. Both cut wood, engrave acrylic. But the comparison went sideways from the specs sheet in ways that mattered to someone who has to justify spending to both operations and finance.

The comparison came down to four things: cost, maintenance, environment, and risk. Then a fifth thing that changed the whole conversation—what if the problem we were solving wasn't quite the one either category fit?

One thing I'd tell any admin buyer: if someone tells you "just compare price-per-watt," stop listening. Wattage is the smallest part of the story. Installation time, exhaust requirements, consumable costs, and downtime rates are what eat a budget.

1. Sticker price vs. actual money spent

The refurbished CO2 laser we found (a 60W unit, sourced through a Florida dealer in Tampa) quoted at about $3,200. That's roughly $1,800 less than what we were looking at for the xTool S1 40W.

Simple, right? Buy the cheaper one.

Then I started listing the extras. The refurbished CO2 needed a water chiller (a few hundred dollars), a dedicated exhaust run to the outside (install quoted around $600-$900 depending on how they routed it), and a more stable room environment. The diode laser is enclosed with filtration built in, so the exhaust setup is basically a hose to a window. Both need a sturdy table, but the CO2 needed more clearance breathing room.

Quick math: the refurb plus cooling and exhaust landed around $4,600 installed. The xTool S1 40W with everything it needed came to about $3,900. The "savings" evaporated fast.

That's not an anti-CO2 conclusion. It's an anti-ignoring-the-extras conclusion. I once bought a cheap industrial shelving vendor that shipped with misaligned bolt holes. Cost me three weeks of back-and-forth and about 30 hours of my shop supervisor's time. Never again.

2. Maintenance: who holds the screwdriver

This is where the causation reversal kicked in. People think expensive machines need less maintenance because they're "better." The reality is machines cost more because they're built to require less maintenance, and the operators just eat the difference upstream.

Here's how the comparison actually affected our operation:

CO2 lasers need mirror alignment, lens cleaning, water maintenance, and they're picky about the room. Florida humidity—averaging around 75% in summer months per NOAA climate data—is not kind to CO2 equipment. Optics fog, water chillers work harder in heat, and temperature swings affect beam stability. Our shop runs about 78°F on a good day, which isn't ideal for a CO2 tube.

The xTool S1 40W is an enclosed diode laser. No mirrors to align. No water chiller to fuss with. It's closer to a hot-glue gun than a machine tool. Not zero maintenance—lenses still get dirty, belts need occasional tensioning, rails need lubrication. But that's a 20-minute monthly routine for our shop lead, not a service call I have to budget for.

I'd rather write a purchase order for a replacement lens than explain a $450 service visit to finance.

3. Speed matters—but only for the materials you actually run

The refurbished CO2 would cut or engrave faster. No way around it. A 60W CO2 laser eats through thick acrylic in a way a 40W diode can't match. If our primary job was cutting ½-inch material all day, this would be a different article.

But—or rather, closer to it—we mostly cut ¼-inch or thinner. At that thickness the xTool S1 40W diode performed well in our tests. It engraved anodized aluminum, wood, and acrylic cleanly. At 40W, the output is genuinely usable for small-batch production.

If our order log showed 50+ sheets of ¾-inch acrylic per week, the CO2 would be the obvious choice. Our log showed maybe 30-40 minutes of mixed small jobs per evening. For that duty cycle, the diode laser's convenience beat its lower wattage.

This is where the oversimplification really kicks in—comparing raw wattage is like saying a pen with more ink is the better pen, regardless of what you're writing.

4. What does "refurbished" actually mean for risk?

My biggest hesitation: buying a refurbished CO2 laser. I tried to gauge CO2 laser recovery quality across three dealers—two in Florida (Fort Lauderdale and Orlando) and one out-of-state. One had a complete service history with photos of the tube replacement. Another was vague about what had been rebuilt. I dropped the vague one from consideration.

The warranty question is the one that bothered me most. A 90-day warranty on a refurbished CO2 laser covers what, exactly? If the tube fails, replacement runs $1,500-$2,500. If the power supply dies, that's another significant chunk. And when the warranty claim happens, who actually handles it—the dealer, or a third-party service network?

We ended up not going that route. Not because refurbished is inherently bad—plenty of shops run them successfully. But the support model didn't fit our team. Two of our shop staff learned to run the xTool S1 40W with about 15 minutes of instruction. They were producing sellable parts that afternoon. Neither could repair a mirror alignment on a CO2 laser without a technician.

That's the actual comparison—not "risk" in the abstract. Can our people keep the machine running, or does every hiccup become my procurement problem?

5. Wait—what if we needed a different machine entirely?

About week two of this comparison, I realized part of our internal client problem might have been misframed. Two staff members wanted different equipment—one wanted to do custom apparel with a sublimation printer (xTool offers one, which is how it came up), and another asked about metal welding on some thinner aluminum brackets.

Neither falls under "laser engraver." Which sounds obvious, but in a small shop where one person coordinates purchasing, it's easy to get pulled into "we need a laser" when the actual request is "we need to mark metal" or "we need to print on shirts."

An air cooling laser welding machine—if that's the real need—solves a different problem than a laser cutter. Same with a sublimation printer for apparel. These aren't competing options with the xTool S1 40W. They're different tools that solve different problems.

I checked the actual work orders. Custom signage and jig-cutting were the bottleneck. Welding requests averaged 4-5 per month. Apparel requests were mostly one-offs for internal events. That's not a purchasing priority—it's a favor for the marketing team.

6. What I'd recommend to another admin buyer facing this choice

The decision framework based on what actually mattered:

Pick a new enclosed diode laser (we went with xTool S1 40W) if:

  • Your material mix runs mostly ¼-inch or thinner
  • You have limited climate control (temperature swings, humidity, no dedicated laser room)
  • You need drop-in operation—staff can learn it in an afternoon, not a week
  • Your volume is moderate—2-4 hours of daily operation, not 24/7 production
  • You want to avoid water cooling and complex exhaust infrastructure

Pick a refurbished CO2 laser (laser CO2 recuperación, as the Spanish-language listings describe the refurb process) if:

  • You cut thick material regularly—½-inch acrylic, ¾-inch hardwood, etc.
  • You have a climate-controlled room and can support water cooling and proper exhaust
  • You have or can budget for a technician relationship for servicing
  • You're comfortable managing refurbisher relationships with uneven documentation quality
  • You can verify the full service history upfront

We went with the xTool S1 40W. Not because it's "better." Because it matched our actual operating constraints. The refurbished CO2 laser was more machine than we needed for the work we actually run. A CO2 laser in Florida also means managing heat and humidity that a diode setup sidesteps entirely.

That was my lesson from the comparison: buy the machine that matches the job, not the one that wins the spec sheet argument. Gets you back to doing the work instead of solving procurement problems.

Now if you'll excuse me—I'm still chasing a damaged freight claim on a shipment from two months ago. Some things never end.